In depth: mattresses explained
Two reviewers on the same mattress rarely agree on every point, and where they differ is worth reading
Tom's Guide and Expert Reviews both cover the Simba Hybrid Pro, the Panda Hybrid Bamboo, the Silentnight Premier Inn 2.0 and the Origin Hybrid, so there are four mattresses with two views on them. On the Simba they agree: Tom's Guide slept on a king for three months and found it a medium-firm with a slightly squishy feel, and Expert Reviews found it comfortable in several positions and noted a bouncy, breathable surface. On the Silentnight they also agree, that it is firm, supportive and strong at the edge.
The Panda is where they split. Expert Reviews calls it firm and measured its surface temperature; Tom's Guide calls it medium-firm and rates the temperature regulation 5 out of 5, but finds the edges weaker than expected. The Origin splits on edges too. The gaps have an explanation in the method: Expert Reviews says it sleeps on each mattress for at least two weeks and up to three months, without giving a length per model, while Tom's Guide gives a period for each of its main picks: one month for the Panda and the Silentnight, five weeks for the DreamCloud, and three months for the Simba and Nectar. Tom's Guide slept on a double for the Panda and a king for the Simba, so the size also differs.
The dates matter as well. Expert Reviews' own review dates are June 2024 for the Origin, September 2024 for the Panda, March 2025 for the Silentnight and April 2025 for the Simba, inside a roundup that was updated on 11 November 2026. A review can pre-date a change to a mattress or its price, which is why every price here was read from the product page on the day and why the Origin, with the oldest review of the top three, is described as placing first on steady rather than recent praise.
Nectar Classic against DreamCloud Hybrid: a foam bed and a spring bed at a £107 price gap
The two share a 25 cm depth, five layers, a 365 night trial and a lifetime style guarantee, and they sit next to each other in the ranking. The Nectar costs £392 at Mattress Next Day and the DreamCloud £499, a difference of £107. Nectar's own price is £449, so the DreamCloud is £50 above that. The Nectar is all foam; the DreamCloud adds a reinforced edge pocket spring unit.
Tom's Guide slept on both in a double, for three months on the Nectar and five weeks on the DreamCloud, and the results mirror each other. The Nectar is great on motion isolation and weak at the edges; the DreamCloud is strong at the edges and a slight weak point on motion. The Nectar is firmer, with Tom's Guide suggesting back and stomach sleepers and warning lightweight sleepers off. The DreamCloud is medium-firm leaning firm and may feel soft to heavier people. The DreamCloud is also the better on heat, according to Tom's Guide, which called its regulation impressive and said the Nectar's foam can sleep stuffy.
The choice therefore turns on your partner and your edges. If your partner is a restless sleeper and you wake easily, the Nectar's motion isolation is the point of the mattress. If you share a double and both sit on the edge or sleep near it, the DreamCloud's edge is. Neither is for hot sleepers who want a measured result; that is the Panda, at £60.30 above the DreamCloud.
The Silentnight Premier Inn 2.0 at £799: what the extra money buys and what it leaves out
The Silentnight costs £389 more than Origin and £239.70 more than Panda. For that money it offers the deepest build here at 28.5 cm, a 1,000 spring zoned system, side handles for rotating, and the best edge rating in the group. Both reviewers back it, with a Best Buy label from Expert Reviews and an excellent edge rating from Tom's Guide.
What it leaves out is a trial and a long guarantee. There is no trial stated on the Premier Inn at Home page, and Tom's Guide reports a 14 day return period. The guarantee is 6 years against 15 for Origin. Tom's Guide also says it needs regular rotation, that lighter side sleepers should avoid it and that hot sleepers may find it warm. A price of £799 with no way to return it after two weeks puts all the risk on the buyer, which is the reason it ranks last in a comparison where trial and guarantee carry as much weight as price.
It is the right choice in a narrow case: you know you like a firm mattress with a pillow top, you want the strongest edge and the deepest build, and you want next day delivery on an order before 2.30pm. Expert Reviews says its Home Editor sleeps on it every night, which is a longer verdict than any trial. If you are unsure about firmness, the Origin and the DreamCloud both leave you a way out for a lower price.
Buying guide: choosing the right mattress
Firmness labels come from the maker, and the reviewers often place the same mattress elsewhere on the scale
The same mattress can be medium-firm on the product page and firm in a review. Origin rates the Hybrid at 6–7 out of 10 and calls it medium-firm, Tom's Guide lists it as firm, and Expert Reviews describes a balance that suits softer and firmer preferences. Nectar gives its Classic 6.5 out of 10 and Tom's Guide puts it on the firmer side. Panda says medium-firm, Tom's Guide agrees, and Expert Reviews calls it firm and too firm for some. A number on one maker's scale does not carry over to another maker's scale, so use the labels to sort mattresses into soft, middle and firm groups and no further. The best mattress for you is the one whose firmness suits your weight and position, not the one with the highest number.
The more useful signal is who each reviewer warns off. Tom's Guide says lighter side sleepers should avoid the Panda and the Silentnight, and lightweight sleepers should avoid the Nectar. It says the DreamCloud may feel too soft for heavier people, and it advises heavier back and stomach sleepers to avoid the Simba. The pattern is simple: the firmer mattresses are flagged for lighter people and the softer ones for heavier people. None of the sources used here gives a body weight at which the advice changes, so that figure is not stated and cannot be worked out from this page.
If you have never slept on anything as firm as a Panda or a Silentnight, the trial matters more than the label. The Silentnight is the wrong first purchase for an undecided buyer, because it has no home trial. The Simba is described as the most cushioned of the group, with a slightly squishy medium-firm feel, so it is the one to look at if your current mattress is soft.
A 365 night trial is worth more than a few pounds off if you are unsure about firmness
Trial length varies more than price does. Nectar and DreamCloud give 365 nights, Simba and Origin 200, Panda and Otty 100, and the Silentnight has none, with only a 14 day return period according to Tom's Guide. Nectar's trial is 165 nights longer than Origin's, and the Nectar costs £18 less at today's sale prices. DreamCloud suggests allowing the first 30 nights to settle in before judging, which on a 100 night trial leaves 70 nights of real decision time and on 365 nights leaves 335.
What a return costs you is part of the trial. DreamCloud says it will collect the mattress free of charge, Simba collects free on a return, and Panda lists free returns. Origin promises a full refund and says returned mattresses go to local charities. Otty advertises a money-back trial. Check the wording on the product page before you order, since these are the makers' own terms, and note that Simba's 10 year guarantee only stays valid with a mattress protector, which Simba sells separately; its TripleShield Bamboo protector for a double was £69 on the product page.
A long trial does not suit everyone. If you would rather buy once and keep the mattress, the Silentnight at £799 from Premier Inn at Home is in stock with next day delivery on orders before 2.30pm, and Expert Reviews' Home Editor sleeps on it nightly. You are relying on the reviews instead of a trial, and they say it is firm.
November sale prices will move, so compare the cost of each year of guarantee as well as the ticket price
Five of the seven mattresses were on sale on 16 November. Simba shows 30% off a £1,299 RRP, a saving of £389.70. Panda shows £559.30 against £799, a saving of £239.70. Origin shows £410 against £508, a figure that includes the value of a free pillow, and Otty shows £559.99 against £624.99. The Nectar is £392 at Mattress Next Day against an RRP of £449. DreamCloud and the Silentnight show no discount at all. A mattress that is cheap because of a sale can return to its RRP while the one at a flat price stays put, so the ranking in this comparison uses the lowest verified price on the day and will change if prices do.
Dividing the price by the guarantee gives a second view. Origin's £410 over 15 years is about £27 a year. Panda's £559.30 and Otty's £559.99 over 10 years are about £56 a year each. Simba's £909.30 over 10 years is about £91 a year, and about £130 a year at its £1,299 RRP. The Silentnight's £799 over 6 years is about £133 a year. Nectar and DreamCloud describe guarantees for as long as you own the mattress, so a figure per year cannot be set for them. A guarantee covers faults, not comfort, and several makers say it is void without a protector, so it is a weaker measure than the trial for deciding whether you will like the mattress.
All prices here are for a double (135 x 190 cm) so that the seven are comparable. If you need a small double (120 x 190 cm), a king (150 x 200 cm) or a super king (180 x 200 cm), the same mattress costs a different amount and the ranking on price may change. Check the size on the product page before you pay, because the best mattress at double size is not automatically the best value at king size.
Hot sleepers should look for a measured result, and only the Panda has one
Expert Reviews warmed the Panda's surface with a heat pad to 50°C and recorded it at 26.9°C four minutes later. Tom's Guide gave it 5 out of 5 for temperature regulation and called it the best of its group. No other mattress on this page comes with a published figure. The others come with the reviewers' impressions, which are useful but cannot be set side by side in the same way.
The impressions point in a clear direction. Tom's Guide calls the DreamCloud's temperature regulation impressive even though it has no cooling materials, rates the Origin's temperature control as good, and says the Otty's works well. Expert Reviews credits the Simba's wool layer with handling temperature better than memory foam only mattresses, and Tom's Guide finds the Simba breathable but less cooling than the Panda. At the other end, Tom's Guide says the Nectar's foam can trap heat, and that the Silentnight does not feel cool and may be too warm for hot sleepers.
The Panda is firm, and that is the trade. Both reviewers say so, and Tom's Guide advises lighter side sleepers against it. If you run hot and also sleep on your side at a lighter weight, the DreamCloud or the Otty are the mattresses with reported good temperature handling and a less firm description. The Panda also has the shortest trial on the page apart from Otty's, at 100 nights, so a firm mattress that turns out wrong is the more expensive mistake to correct.
In a double bed the edge is half of your mattress, so read the edge verdicts twice
A 135 cm double gives two sleepers 67.5 cm each. A small double at 120 cm gives 60 cm each, and a king at 150 cm gives 75 cm. If one of you sleeps near the edge, or you sit on the side of the bed to dress, the edge behaviour counts for more than it does on a single. Tom's Guide rates the Silentnight's edge support as excellent because of firmer perimeter coils, and Expert Reviews could lie at its edge without the mattress buckling. That is the best result here.
The Simba and the DreamCloud both get a strong rating from Tom's Guide. The Simba's is qualified: it is less stable at the corners. The DreamCloud's comes from a reinforced edge spring unit. The Nectar is the other way round: Tom's Guide names edge support as a weakness while praising its motion isolation as great. The Otty's edge support could be better according to Tom's Guide.
Two mattresses split the reviewers. The Expert Reviews reviewer and her partner noticed little dipping at the Origin's edge, while Tom's Guide says the edge support could be better. For the Panda, Expert Reviews found support right up to the edges while Tom's Guide found them weaker than expected and said its testers felt unsteady sitting on them. When reviewers disagree, the safest reading is that the edge is average, and that you should plan accordingly if you sit on the bed edge. If you sleep alone in the middle of a double, none of this matters much and the comfort and price criteria are the better guide.
Depth and spring counts only compare inside the same construction
Depth is the one build figure most makers state: 28.5 cm for the Silentnight, 28 cm for the Simba, 26 cm for the Origin, and 25 cm for the Nectar, DreamCloud and Otty. The Panda's page states none, and the Origin's page lists 26 cm in its construction notes and 35 cm in its size selector, so treat its depth as 26 cm with a question mark. A deeper mattress has room for more layers, but the reviewers do not say that depth by itself made any mattress better, and the Silentnight, the deepest, ranks last here for other reasons.
Spring counts are quoted as maximums. Simba says up to 4,800 springs, Otty up to 2,000, the Silentnight 1,000 and Panda up to 960. Origin gives five spring zones and DreamCloud a reinforced edge unit, neither with a count. The Simba's figure counts microsprings in two layers, and the Otty's counts pocket springs, so the two numbers describe different parts. An 'up to' figure may also describe the largest size, so a double can have fewer.
The Nectar has no springs at all. Its construction is five foam layers, and it weighs 31.08 kg according to Nectar. Tom's Guide reports strong off-gassing at first for the Nectar, and says the Simba is heavy to lift and rotate. If you will move or turn the mattress yourself, or live up several flights of stairs, those two comments are worth more than the spring count. If you will lay it once and leave it, the build criterion should matter least in your decision, which is why it carries only a tenth of the weighting here.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best mattress in the UK in 2026?
According to our comparison of Tom's Guide and Expert Reviews findings and the manufacturers' data, the best mattress for a double bed is the Origin Hybrid at £410. It has a 200 night trial and a 15 year warranty, and Expert Reviews gave it five stars and a Recommended Award in June 2024. The best choice for you still depends on firmness, heat and price, which the rest of this page compares.
Which mattress has the longest trial?
The Nectar Classic Memory Foam and the DreamCloud Hybrid both give 365 nights, according to their own product pages. The Simba Hybrid Pro and the Origin Hybrid give 200 nights, and the Panda Hybrid Bamboo and the Otty Original Hybrid give 100. The Silentnight Premier Inn 2.0 has no trial, and Tom's Guide reports a 14 day return period.
How much does a good double mattress cost?
Among the seven here, the lowest verified price for a double (135 x 190 cm) on 16 November 2026 was £392 and the highest was £909.30. Five of them were discounted from RRPs of £449 to £1,299, so prices can change quickly. The middle of the group sits between £410 and £559.30.
Is a mattress in a box different from a normal mattress?
The sources used here do not describe how each mattress is packed or delivered, so that is not stated. What they do show is that most of these brands sell online with a home trial, from 100 nights at Panda and Otty to 365 at Nectar and DreamCloud. The Silentnight is sold through the Premier Inn at Home shop with no trial. Check the delivery section of the product page for packaging and room of choice options.
Which of these mattresses is best for hot sleepers?
The Panda Hybrid Bamboo is the only one with a published measurement. Expert Reviews recorded its surface falling from 50°C to 26.9°C in four minutes after heating, and Tom's Guide gave it 5 out of 5 for temperature regulation. It is firm, and Tom's Guide warns lighter side sleepers away. Tom's Guide calls the DreamCloud's regulation impressive, which is a less firm option.
Is a firm mattress better than a medium-firm one?
Neither is better in general; the reviewers' warnings depend on who is sleeping. Tom's Guide says lighter side sleepers should avoid the Panda and the Silentnight, lightweight sleepers the Nectar, and heavier people may find the DreamCloud too soft. The makers' firmness scales also differ from one another, so a trial is the safer test than the label.
Do I need a mattress protector?
Simba's product page says a mattress protector is required to keep its 10 year guarantee valid, and its TripleShield Bamboo protector for a double was £69 on the page. The other makers' pages used here do not state the same condition in the parts we read. Check the guarantee terms before you order, since a stain can void cover.
Which mattress has the strongest edges?
The Silentnight Premier Inn 2.0. Tom's Guide rates its edge support as excellent because of firmer perimeter coils, and Expert Reviews could lie at its edge without the mattress buckling. The Simba and DreamCloud are both rated strong by Tom's Guide. The Nectar's edge support is a named weakness, and the Otty's could be better.
What happens to my old mattress?
It depends on the maker. DreamCloud and Nectar charge £60 for old mattress removal with premium delivery, according to their pages. Origin lists a mattress disposal service at £54. Panda says its free service removes an old mattress, and Otty offers old mattress collection as a paid option at checkout. Simba and the Silentnight pages did not state a removal option in the parts read.
Can I buy a different size or firmness of the same mattress?
Yes, but the price changes and the ranking may as well. All prices on this page are for a double (135 x 190 cm). Simba, Origin and Panda also list small double sizes, and Otty lists small double, EU double, king and super king, along with firmer ranges such as an Extra Firm hybrid rated 9 out of 10. Variants share the reviews of the model only if the page says they are the same mattress.
How were the prices and stock checked?
Each price and size was read from the retailer's product page on 16 November 2026 and is for a double. The Silentnight was in stock with next day delivery, and Mattress Next Day listed three Nectar doubles left. DreamCloud and Otty pages showed the double as available, but DreamCloud gave no delivery time we could confirm. Sale prices were running for Black Friday, so check the price at the shop.